Where you end and the institution begins


A clinician came into my office a while back to ask permission for something she didn’t need permission for. It was a scheduling thing that sat completely inside her own judgment and she’d worked out the right answer before she ever knocked. She just wanted me to say it was okay. I told her it was okay and then I sat there after she left feeling curious about the whole exchange, because I know that walk. I did it for twenty-five years in a manufacturing plant and I did it in a church. Now I’m on the other side of the desk and somebody is doing it to me.

There are sixteen of us at the practice and I signed the paperwork that made the thing exist, which means I’m now the institution somebody else is currently trying not to disappear into. Nobody warns you about that part.

She wasn’t afraid of me, which is the part worth sitting with. There’s nothing in how that place runs that would teach a person to check before using their own judgment on a scheduling question. She carried that in with her the way all of us carry it in, and my office just happened to be the nearest thing shaped like an authority.

Offices are the easy version though. A job can only take so much of you and at the end of the day you get to leave it. The system that actually owns people is the one a lot of you are going to drive to next week with a pie in the back seat.

There’s a man I’ve worked with for a couple of years now. He’s forty-eight and he runs a company with thirty-some employees. He makes payroll every two weeks and he’s fired people who deserved it and a few who didn’t. He’s the one everybody in his industry calls when something has gone badly wrong. Competent is the best word for describing him. Nobody who works for that man would describe him as easy to push around.

He drives four hours to his parents’ house every November and somewhere between the driveway and the second afternoon he stops existing.

It starts small enough that he misses it. His dad asks a question about the business in a tone suggesting the answer is going to be disappointing and he hears himself explaining, which is something he hasn’t done for another human being in a decade. His older brother runs the same joke he’s been running since 1989 and he laughs at it. By Thursday evening somebody says something at the table that he believes is just plain wrong and he nods, because the alternative is a long tense night and everybody driving home angry at each other.

He gets in his truck on Friday and spends four hours furious with himself. Then he does the whole thing again the following November.

Murray Bowen is one of the most consequential thinkers in the history of family therapy. He spent his career on this exact problem and his real contribution was to stop studying individuals. He proposed that we can’t fully understand a person’s emotional life without understanding the relationship systems in which that person developed and continues to live. He looked at a family as one emotional unit rather than a collection of separate people and found that anxiety moves through it like weather, and that what any one member does is mostly a response to what the unit is doing. The man in the truck isn’t weak. He’s one component in a system that’s older than he is and that was running before he ever showed up.

The idea Bowen is known for is differentiation of self, and it means something different from what people assume. It has nothing to do with needing people less. Differentiation is the capacity to stay in close emotional contact with a group while remaining a separate person inside it, and the entire difficulty is doing both of those at once. Walking away is easy and merging is easy. Staying at the table and remaining yourself is the thing almost nobody manages well.

Bowen split a person into what he called solid self and pseudo-self, and that distinction is the whole explanation for the man in the truck. Pseudo-self is everything you picked up from a group without ever examining it. It’s acquired and it’s negotiable so under pressure it gets traded away to lower the temperature or to stay in somebody’s good graces, and it shifts depending on which room you’re standing in. Solid self is whatever is left when the pressure is on. It’s built out of positions you arrived at by actually thinking them through and it doesn’t get traded away at any price.

Here’s the part that surprises people. The man who runs thirty employees is mostly pseudo-self too. He didn’t build that version of himself by sitting down and working out who he wanted to be. The role he was in built it. He’s in a system that rewards decisiveness and hands him authority and he’s taken the shape it rewards, the same way he takes the shape of every system he walks into. It holds up beautifully right until he walks into a building where the rules were set in 1981 and he’s the youngest son again. That’s why it collapses in a kitchen. There’s less underneath it than anybody can see from the outside, including him.

Bowen’s other idea is the one that’ll be running in your family within about ninety minutes of everybody arriving. Most people called it triangulation. When two people in a system get anxious with each other the tension is more than either one can hold, so they pull in a third person and the anxiety spreads out and settles. Your mother can’t talk to your sister so she talks to you about your sister. Two of your siblings route everything they have against each other through your father. A kid gets pulled into the middle of a marriage and spends thirty years there without ever being told what the job was.

It works, which is the problem. Triangulation genuinely lowers the temperature in the short run and it guarantees nothing ever gets resolved, because the two people who actually have the problem are now comfortable enough to never deal with it.

Once you can see triangulation you can’t unsee them and refusing the third chair is simple and unpleasant. If somebody brings you their grievance about a person who’s in the next room and you tell them it sounds like a conversation to have with that person, you’ll be considered the difficult one for a while.

You find out how much solid self you’re actually carrying on the day the group has a consensus and you don’t.

Everybody at the table has landed on the same answer. It’s defensible and nobody’s being cruel and something in you knows it’s wrong. What happens in the next ten seconds is the whole thing. Most people find out in that moment that their position was pseudo-self, and the tell is that it never feels like caving. It feels like reconsidering. You come up with a genuinely reasonable argument for why they might have a point and then you believe it, and it came from the pressure rather than from anything new you thought of. I’ve done that more times than I care to put in this writing.

So what does the man in the truck actually do differently next year.

He says one thing. Not a speech and not a confrontation, just the single sentence he was planning to swallow, and then he stays in his chair while the room adjusts around it. He lets the next three things go, because somebody who objects to everything has stopped being differentiated and started being reactive. Bowen would tell you that’s the same fusion running backward. He decides before he leaves the house which two or three positions aren’t for sale and he treats everything else as negotiable, because a man with firm views on every subject is rigid rather than differentiated.

And, he stays in contact with the people he disagrees with, which is the part almost everybody skips. Differentiation in a family means holding your position and then passing the potatoes to the person who hates it. Cutting them off is easier and it means you never find out whether you could have held your ground and stayed at the table.

Which brings up the thing people reach for first. Some families you should stop going to. There are genuinely harmful ones and spending the holiday in a place that damages you to prove your own development is its own kind of foolishness. The honest question is whether you’re staying away because you thought it through or because the discomfort got high enough that leaving was the only thing you could think about. One of those you can explain calmly a year later. The other one you’re still defending.

I think about the clinician who came to ask for permission she didn’t need. I can’t give her differentiation. Nobody can hand that to another person, and the whole point is that it gets built from the inside. What I can do is run a place where using her own judgment never costs her anything and where disagreeing with me is followed by an entirely ordinary afternoon and nobody has to read my mood before deciding what they think. That’s about all any system has to offer.

I spent twenty-five years in a building that was never going to offer me any of it, and I figured out far too late that it was never the building’s job.

If you’re driving somewhere next week, you’re going to a place that has been assigning you a shape since before you could talk. It’ll start handing you that shape in the driveway. Whether you take it is the only part of the whole arrangement that was ever up to you.

Peace my friends,

~Travis

Up next week: The Return With the Elixir

This essay is part of a year-long weekly exploration of how we become who we are, and why change often begins in places we were never taught to look.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Mysterious Flow

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading